PovertyFrontiers.orgSkip Repetitive Navigation USAID: From the American people 
Click here for low-bandwidth/disability access
Search  |  Request Account  |  Your status: guest (Suggest and Discuss)
Sections


LOGIN
Username:
Password:


To view the documents we offer in PDF format, you may need to download the Adobe Reader.

Add my Knowledge Create Knowledge Relationships Page Options Edit
Topic

Law Undermines Future Generations of Poor

Report from Spier Estate, South Africa, March 26, 2007
    

If poverty alleviation programmes are to have any real impact they have to be sustainable beyond “the first generation” so that the children of the poor stand a chance of improving their lives.

In a paper titled, “Poverty and the Developmental State,” delivered at the Living on the Margins conference currently underway at the Spier Estate near Stellenbosch, University of Cape Town poverty researchers Sue Parnell and Edgar Pieterse said the South African government was short-sighted in its attempts to help the poor. “There is no question the political will to help the poor exists,” said Parnell. “What is a problem is that many of the steps being taken now will not improve the lives of future generations of the poor.” 

She referred specifically to Act 113 - the Development Facilitation Act. This legislation allows compromise on the usual laws that govern the establishment of communities in areas zoned for low-cost housing. “It makes it legal to cut corners to keep costs down.”

While this kind of compromise introduced a host of controversial issues in the development of low-cost housing, Parnell and Pieterse’s concern with the legislation is that it unwittingly maintains the status quo with the poor destined to stay poor despite the attempt at a leg-up by government. “Any relevant development by the formal sector within these communities becomes impossible,” she said, “because the infrastructure to support development doesn’t exist or has been compromised.”

“A major shopping chain couldn’t build a complex within a low cost community because, for example, the pipes used for sewerage might be too small to support the development.” People living in new low cost communities were destined to a life of spaza shops and street trading never enjoying the benefits (like easy access to work of major employers) of the first economy.

Parnell asked for a show of hands of those who had heard of Act 113 and, on seeing none, she observed that most South Africans were unaware of the legislation never mind the impact it was having. “We need to go back and re-look at territory we find uncomfortable,” she said.

The conference, which has drawn speakers from across the world, focuses on current theories on poverty and runs until Wednesday. It is co-hosted by UWC’s Programme for Land and Agrarian Studies, Isandla Institute and the Chronic Poverty Research Centre and sponsored by USAID, the Development Bank of South Africa and the National Research Foundation.




The information provided on this web site is not official U.S. government information, and does not represent the views or positions of the U.S. Agency for International Development or the U.S. Government. Link for official information on USAID and the PASSN team site on usaid.gov.

The State at the Margins: Poverty, Inequality and Informality Plenary
Day One
March 26, 2007
2:30-3:30pm

Linking Informality and Chronic Poverty
Armando Barrientos
Poverty and the Developmental State: Realising ‘Third Generation
Rights’ at the Urban and Regional Scale
Sue Parnell & Edgar Pieterse

Chairperson
Mirjam van Donk 
>Access Abstracts